Amazon’s holiday advertising has taken an unusual turn. The company’s new spot, “Joy Delivered,” launched earlier this month. It follows a traveller named Joy after snow grounds every flight on Christmas Eve, sending her home by bus, boat and a taxi driven by a giant. Along the way, she hands Amazon parcels meant for her family to the strangers who help her.
The ad is polished and film-like, carried by a new version of The Beatles’ “Golden Slumbers.” But the more interesting story is the ad it replaced.
Amazon already had a near-perfect Christmas ad
In 2023, Amazon released “Joy Ride.” Three older women sit on a snowy hill and watch children sledding. One orders seat cushions from Amazon, the box arrives, and moments later they are flying down the hill themselves. There is no dialogue, just an instrumental of “In My Life.”
That ad earned the maximum 5.8 stars in System1’s testing. Last year, Amazon did something rare for a major marketer: it ran the same ad again. “Joy Ride” scored 5.7, placing it in the top 1% of all ads measured that year.
The data says ads don’t wear out
System1 has reviewed more than 50,000 ads and found that scores barely shift as creative ages. Some of the strongest campaigns actually improve as viewers get to know them. Coca-Cola has run “Holidays Are Coming” every Christmas since 1995, and it still tests at five stars, according to System1.
Broader evidence points the same way: an average brand-building campaign reaches its maximum impact about two to three years into execution. Seasonal work can run for decades.
Why marketers still chase the new
Jo Shoesmith, Amazon’s global chief brand officer, told Adweek that people want nostalgia but also “something they haven’t seen before.” The analysis sees this as a contradiction. Marketers live with their own creative for at least 9,000 hours before it launches, so they are often tired of it long before most of the target audience has noticed.
That doesn’t mean brands should never refresh. But swapping an already-made, already-proven and already-loved ad for something less certain adds risk and cost without clear evidence of wear-out.
What marketers can do
Before retiring a seasonal asset, teams can take three practical steps:
- Benchmark the current ad’s score, sales or brand lift before declaring it finished.
- Treat familiarity as evidence that brand building is working, not as a flaw.
- Let proven seasonal creative run again, as Coca-Cola has for three decades.
The new film was shot around Dunedin, New Zealand—where Christmas falls in summer—which is another reminder that a snowy story can look right while missing a local detail. Still, the emotional structure is built to land.
For marketing teams, the lesson is not that new creative is wrong. It is that “new” should be justified by evidence, not by internal boredom. Amazon showed last year that a repeat can still be a top performer. The real advantage is patience.




